Hertsmere councillors voted on 5 November to refuse 700 homes at Compass Park, north of Farm Way, Bushey. The Secretary of State now has 21 days to step in.
Hertsmere councillors have voted to refuse the 700-home Compass Park scheme on Green Belt fields north of Farm Way in Bushey. The Planning Committee took the decision on Thursday 5 November, following its officers’ advice.
It is not quite final. Because the scheme is for more than 150 homes, the council must first tell the Secretary of State it intends to refuse. The government then has 21 days to decide whether to call the application in and decide it nationally.
The vote was 11 to 1, by our count of the roll call on the council’s webcast of the meeting. Councillor Christian Gray was the only member to vote against refusal.
Why it was refused
The application, 25/0972/FULEI, came from Latimer Developments, Hill Residential and MCF Trading. The land belongs to the Freemasons’ charity, the applicants’ speaker told the committee. The scheme proposed:
- up to 700 homes, half of them affordable
- a care home of up to 70 bedrooms
- land for a two-form-entry primary school
- 22.76 hectares of public open space, including a community park
- shops, community space and a pub around a village green
The case turned on one payment. Hertfordshire County Council asked for £7,596,369 towards secondary school places. The developers refused it. They say the county’s own figures show spare secondary places in the area.
Without that money, officers said, the scheme failed the government’s Green Belt “Golden Rules”. That made it inappropriate development in the Green Belt. The officer report gave two reasons for refusal:
- Green Belt. The benefits do not “clearly outweigh” the harm to the Green Belt and the other harms identified.
- Secondary schools. The scheme does not secure the money the county says is needed.
Officers accepted much of the developers’ case. They found the land is “grey belt”, the weaker category of Green Belt that can be built on if a scheme meets the Golden Rules. They also said Hertsmere has far less than five years’ supply of housing land.
The developers had agreed the other big payments in the report. They included £7,063,396 for primary schools and free land for the new school, £1,218,875 for GP surgeries, £1,186,295 for special school places and £270,487 for the ambulance service.
What was said on the night
Speaking for the applicants, a representative of the developers said the refusal “turns on a single issue, a disputed secondary education contribution”. He told councillors that Hertsmere’s housing land supply was under a year. He warned that “the likely outcome is a Secretary of State intervention or a costly appeal”.
A resident speaking against the scheme, and a borough councillor speaking for residents as community advocate, both urged the committee to follow the officers. The councillor called it “a substantial and permanent change to the character of our community”.
Councillor Maxie Allen moved refusal. The developers, he said, “have to cough up what the education authority say they must, and they won’t.”
Asked whether the reasons would stand up at appeal, officers said they believed so. On education, the council would rely on the county council as its expert witness. The committee’s update sheet says county officers have confirmed they would help defend the education case at an inquiry.
Who objected
The council notified 2,168 neighbours and heard from 612 people. Of those, 602 objected, 2 supported the scheme and 8 were neutral, according to the officer report. Objectors raised the loss of the gap between Bushey and Bushey North, traffic, and pressure on schools and GP surgeries.
The site is not allocated for housing in the council’s new draft Local Plan. It was a candidate for 802 homes in this year’s first draft.
What happens next
- The council consults the Secretary of State for 21 days.
- If the government does not call the application in, council officers issue the refusal, with the reasons in the report.
- If it is called in, a planning inspector would hold an inquiry and the Secretary of State would decide. The council would defend its refusal.
- Once refused, the developers can appeal. They have six months to do so.
The six-month appeal window is the standard limit for a major application under the government’s appeal rules.
What it means for you
- Nothing will be built yet. No homes can go ahead unless the government calls the scheme in and approves it, or the developers win an appeal.
- An appeal is possible. The developers’ speaker raised one himself. Just across Little Bushey Lane, an inspector allowed Redrow’s appeal for 280 homes on 3 November and ordered Hertsmere to pay part of Redrow’s costs.
- Have your say on where homes go. Comments on the new Local Plan close at 11.59pm on 19 November.
The same meeting deferred the data centre on the former Mercure Hotel site off the A41, also in Bushey. Read the latest on that application. For other schemes, see our planning news page.
Have your say