A planning inspector has granted Redrow up to 280 homes on paddocks off Little Bushey Lane, Bushey. Hertsmere must also pay part of the developer's costs.
Up to 280 homes will be built on paddocks off Little Bushey Lane in Bushey. A planning inspector allowed developer Redrow’s appeal on 3 November, overturning the refusal Hertsmere councillors voted for in March.
The inspector also ordered Hertsmere Borough Council to pay part of Redrow’s appeal costs. The decision found that parts of the council’s refusal were not backed by evidence. The amount has not been set.
The site is on the eastern edge of Bushey, between existing housing and the M1. It is the same ground, in part, where a bid for 310 homes was thrown out on appeal in 2023. This time the site is smaller and leaves out the land in Flood Zones 2 and 3.
What has been approved
The appeal decision grants outline permission under reference 24/1522/OUT. Only the access from Little Bushey Lane is fixed, so the layout and design of the homes come later.
The permission and its signed legal agreement include:
- up to 280 homes, with 50% affordable
- a mobility and community hub
- about 6.85 hectares of public green space and play areas
- five years of funding for an extra bus service, plus closer bus stops
- at least 10% biodiversity net gain on site
- payments towards education, health care, walking and cycling routes
Redrow must apply for approval of the details within three years. Building must start within two years of the last of those details being approved.
How the council’s position fell apart
The decision and the separate costs decision set out the timeline.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| 19 March 2026 | Officers recommend approval. The Planning Committee refuses it. |
| 2 May 2026 | Redrow appeals. |
| 17 July 2026 | After a further committee meeting and legal advice, the council says it no longer opposes permission. |
| 7 October 2026 | Council approves its draft Local Plan, which allocates this site for 280 homes. |
| 3 November 2026 | Appeal allowed, partial costs awarded against the council. |
That change of mind came after a new Green Belt study treated Bushey as a town rather than a large built-up area. The inspector accepted that this justified the council’s new position on the Green Belt and on landscape harm.
The inspector did not accept it for the rest of the refusal. Councillors had also cited highways mitigation, flood risk and an unsustainable location. The costs decision found the council had identified no evidence capable of supporting those three points, against the views of the statutory consultees and an independent flood review the council commissioned itself.
Redrow had asked for all its costs. The award is limited to the work on those three points, up to the council’s change of position. If the two sides cannot agree a figure, the Senior Courts Costs Office will assess it.
Why the inspector said yes
The site is now classed as grey belt, so the homes are not “inappropriate” development in the Green Belt. Paddocks count, because the national definition does not depend on land having been built on before.
The inspector said the council’s housing land supply stands at only 0.98 years, and gave substantial weight to the homes, the affordable housing and compliance with the government’s “Golden Rules” for Green Belt development.
The decision did find harm. The scheme conflicts with local policies protecting the character of the area. There would be a major adverse effect during construction, easing over time to a limited one.
What residents told the inquiry
Residents raised traffic, flooding and sewage, and the inspector acknowledged why they were concerned. On visits to Little Bushey Lane at school run and peak times, the inspector saw parked cars reduce parts of it to a single lane.
The decision still found no harm to highway safety:
- Traffic: most nearby junctions would see rises of under 10%, and most of those under 5%.
- Worst junction: Little Bushey Lane, Aldenham Road and Bushey Mill Lane was already over its theoretical capacity at the 2023 appeal. It would get 4.6% more traffic.
- Flooding: the county’s flood authority raised no objection, and the council’s independent reviewer called the modelling robust.
- Sewers: Thames Water said the scheme does not materially affect the network. A condition covers sewage capacity.
The stables
The tenant of Harts Farm told the inquiry that about 40 horses graze the land, and that losing it would inevitably close the business. The stables are also used by disabled riders from the Life Enhancement Group twice a week.
The inspector gave that loss moderate weight, noting the rolling annual lease, and recognised a possible negative impact on disabled users. The decision says this does not outweigh the benefits of the homes.
What it means for you
If you live near Little Bushey Lane, the principle is now settled. Your next chance to comment is on the detailed application for layout and design, and we will report it when it is lodged.
The Planning Committee considers the 700-home Compass Park scheme at 6pm on 5 November. That scheme also takes access from Little Bushey Lane. The committee’s update sheet says the county has tested the two schemes together and raises no objection, subject to conditions and payments. For the wider picture, see our Borehamwood planning news page.
No figure for the costs award exists yet. We will report it if the council publishes one.
Have your say