Councillors refused the 700-home Compass Park plan north of Farm Way, Bushey, on 5 November over a refused £7.6m secondary school payment. The full report.

Updated 9 November: the Planning Committee voted to refuse the scheme on Thursday 5 November, by 11 votes to 1 on our count of the webcast. The council must now consult the Secretary of State for 21 days before the refusal is issued. Read our report on the decision.

Hertsmere’s planning officers recommended refusing the 700-home Compass Park scheme on fields north of Farm Way in Bushey. The Planning Committee considered it on Thursday 5 November at the Civic Offices in Borehamwood.

The officer report turns on one payment. Hertfordshire County Council wants £7,596,369 towards secondary school places. The developers say no secondary contribution is justified. Without it, officers say the scheme breaks the government’s Green Belt “Golden Rules” and should be refused.

What is proposed

The application, 25/0972/FULEI, was lodged on 1 July 2025 by Latimer Developments, Hill Residential and MCF Trading. The 48.38-hectare site sits between Bournehall Avenue, Hayfield Close and Farm Way to the south and Little Bushey Lane to the north and east. It is Green Belt, in the Bushey St James ward.

The scheme includes:

  • up to 700 homes, half of them affordable, including 10 self-build plots
  • a care home of up to 70 bedrooms
  • 2.2 hectares of land for a two-form-entry primary school (420 pupils)
  • up to 1,712 square metres of shops, community space and a pub around a village green
  • 22.76 hectares of public open space, including a 15.82-hectare community park and the 3.77-hectare Local Wildlife Site, kept and enhanced
  • road access from Little Bushey Lane and Farm Way

The first phase is a detailed plan for 200 homes, all the open space and the Little Bushey Lane entrance. Of those 200 homes, 103 would be flats or maisonettes and 97 houses, two to three storeys high. Half would be affordable: 37 affordable rent, 38 social rent and 25 shared ownership.

Why officers say refuse

Officers accept a lot of the developers’ case. The report finds the site is “grey belt”, the new category of weaker Green Belt land that can be built on if a scheme meets the Golden Rules. It says Hertsmere’s housing land supply is “substantially below” five years. The 2025 Housing Delivery Test found the borough built just 26% of the homes it needed over three years.

The sticking point is schools. The county says there will not be enough secondary places when the estate’s children reach that age. It points out that peak secondary demand from a large estate can come 13 years or more after it is finished. It also counts pupils who cross between Bushey and Watford schools.

The developers dispute the county’s method. They say the Bushey and Radlett school planning area has forecast spare places. Officers side with the county.

The report gives two reasons for refusal:

  • Green Belt. Without the school money the scheme fails the Golden Rules, so it counts as inappropriate development in the Green Belt. Its benefits do not “clearly outweigh” that harm and the other harms identified.
  • Secondary schools. It fails to secure the money the county says is needed for the extra demand.

The other harms officers list are the change to the site’s rural character, “a low level of harm” to the historic Bushey Grange parkland, and the loss of about 25 hectares of moderate quality farmland.

What the developers have agreed to pay

The report shows the developers have agreed to every other major payment they were asked for, even where they dispute it. That includes the full £7,063,396 primary school contribution and free land for the school.

Bar chart of contributions sought for Compass Park, Bushey: secondary schools £7.60 million (refused by the developers), primary schools £7.06 million, GP surgeries £1.22 million, special school places £1.19 million, ambulance service £0.27 million
Chart by The Borehamwood Post. Source: Hertsmere Planning Committee report, 5 November 2026
Share this chartFacebookWhatsAppX
Contribution Amount Agreed?
Secondary education £7,596,369 No
Primary education, plus school land at nil cost £7,063,396 Yes
GP surgeries (NHS ICB) £1,218,875 Yes, by letter of 4 September 2026
Special school places (Breakspeare School expansion) £1,186,295 Yes
Ambulance service £270,487 Yes, by letter of 4 September 2026

Transport payments listed in the report include £1.5 million to run the 306 bus more often and £800,000 for a dedicated bus service in the second phase.

What residents said

The council notified 2,168 neighbours. It received comments from 612 people: 602 against, 2 in support and 8 neutral, according to the officer report. Many objections came in template form.

Objectors raised the loss of the gap between Bushey and Bushey North, pressure on schools, GP surgeries and Watford hospital, and traffic. Several pointed out that the site was dropped from the council’s draft Local Plan.

That history matters. The site was a draft allocation for around 750 homes in the 2021 plan, which was later set aside. It returned as a candidate site of 802 homes in this year’s first draft. But it is not allocated in the Regulation 19 Local Plan now out for comment. Officers say the new plan is too early in its preparation to carry weight in this decision.

A refusal is not the final word

Because the scheme is for 150 homes or more, a 2026 government direction applies. If councillors vote to refuse, the council must first consult the Secretary of State, who can call the application in and decide it.

The recommendation asks councillors to delegate that step to the head of planning. If the application is not called in, permission is then refused. If it is called in, the council would defend its refusal.

What it means for you

  • The decision. Councillors refused the scheme on 5 November, subject to the Secretary of State. Here is what happens next.
  • The Local Plan. If you want a say on where homes go across the borough, comments on the new Local Plan close at 11.59pm on 19 November. Here is how to comment.

The same meeting deferred a data centre on the former Mercure Hotel site off the A41, also in Bushey St James ward. Read our report on that application. For other schemes across the borough, see our planning news page.