Councillors deferred the 200MW data centre at the old Mercure Hotel off the A41, Bushey, on 5 November. They want answers on water, height and payments.
Updated 18 November: the application returns to the Planning Committee on Thursday 26 November, still recommended for approval, with paler cladding, weekday-only generator testing and a larger community payments package. Read what has changed.
Updated 9 November: on Thursday 5 November the Planning Committee voted to defer this application, against the officers’ advice to approve it. According to the council’s webcast of the meeting, councillors deferred it “on all grounds”. They want more information from Affinity Water on supplying the site, further talks on the section 106 payments, and more on the height and design of the buildings. The application will come back to a later committee. The same meeting refused the 700-home Compass Park scheme.
Hertsmere’s planning officers recommended approving a data centre campus on the former Mercure Hotel site off the A41 in Bushey. It would have four data centre buildings up to 36.25 metres tall and about 200 megawatts of computing capacity.
The Planning Committee considered it on Thursday 5 November at the Civic Offices in Borehamwood. The council received 1,184 objections and 4 letters of support, according to the officer report.
What is proposed
The application, 25/1781/FUL, was lodged on 15 December 2025 by Ark Estates 5 Ltd. The 7.3-hectare site sits on the corner of the A41 and Sandy Lane, in the Bushey St James ward. Its postal address is Tylers Way, Watford. It is Green Belt. The hotel and a house at 1-2 Burn Close are both empty.
The campus would include:
- four data centre buildings of five floors each, up to 36.25 metres high including rooftop plant
- a five-storey reception and office building up to 20 metres high
- two electricity substations up to 11 metres high
- 119 car parking spaces and 144 cycle spaces
- the main entrance from the A41, using the old hotel access, with emergency access from Sandy Lane
The buildings total 131,040 square metres of floor space. Each data centre building has its own back-up generators. The applicant intends to run them on hydrotreated vegetable oil “wherever possible”, rather than diesel, and that would be secured by condition.
Power would come from National Grid substations at Letchmore Heath and Uxbridge Moor. The applicant says these are high-voltage connections separate from the local network that supplies homes.
Why officers say approve
The site already has permission for warehouses. Outline permission for up to 14,865 square metres of storage was granted in 2022, and for up to 30,000 square metres in 2023.
It is also a draft employment allocation (site HBUSA11) in the council’s Regulation 19 Local Plan, though officers give that only limited weight at this stage.
Officers conclude that the whole site counts as “grey belt”, the weaker Green Belt land the government now allows to be built on in some cases. They give weight to the government’s designation of data centres as Critical National Infrastructure.
The applicant’s figures, as set out in the report:
- 470 construction jobs and 255 permanent jobs
- about £372 million a year of economic output
- £19.2 million in business rates
The applicant’s needs assessment, by Savills, says there will still be a shortfall of about 420 megawatts of data centre capacity in the Hemel Hempstead “availability zone”, which includes the site, by 2035, even if every scheme in the pipeline is built.
Neither water company objected. Affinity Water and Thames Water both asked for conditions, including one on sewage treatment capacity. Hertfordshire Fire and Rescue did not object, subject to a condition on hydrants.
Approval would be subject to a section 106 agreement. That includes £91,500 to Hertfordshire County Council for bus stops outside the site or a shuttle bus to nearby stations, and £6,000 over five years for monitoring the travel plan. If the agreement is not signed within six months, officers would be able to refuse the application.
What objectors said
The council notified 1,027 neighbours and received comments from 1,190 people. The main objections, as the report summarises them:
- the buildings are too big and tall for a semi-rural edge, and half the site is undeveloped
- electricity use, which objectors put at about 1,910 gigawatt hours a year, or four and a half times Hertsmere’s current use
- water demand in a drought, and wastewater capacity
- round-the-clock noise from cooling plant and generators, including for the neighbouring traveller site
- a construction period objectors say will last nine to ten years, with lorries on the A41, Sandy Lane and Hilfield Lane
- few permanent jobs for the scale of the impact
The Letchmore Heath Village Trust objected. It said the applicant relies on “a flawed application of grey belt policy” and that job creation “will also be minimal”.
The council’s climate change officer had not given final comments when the report was written. They will be reported to the committee on the night.
What it means for you
- Its return. The application was deferred on 5 November and comes back to the Planning Committee on Thursday 26 November at 6pm. Meetings are filmed and broadcast live.
- Speak. One person can speak for and one against, for three minutes each. You must phone 020 8207 7550 between 10am and 4pm on the day of the meeting, first come first served.
- Roads. Officers propose a condition that no work starts until the council approves a construction management plan, covering lorry numbers, routes and traffic management.
The same meeting voted to refuse the 700-home Compass Park scheme north of Farm Way, Bushey, subject to the Secretary of State. Read our report on that decision.
Have your say