The data centre plan for the old Mercure Hotel off the A41 returns on 26 November with paler panels, limits on generator tests and a bigger community package.

The data centre campus planned for the former Mercure Hotel site off the A41 in Bushey goes back to Hertsmere’s Planning Committee on Thursday 26 November. Councillors deferred it on 5 November. The developer has since changed the colour of the buildings but not their size.

Officers still recommend approval, according to an addendum report in the agenda. The committee meets at 6pm at the Civic Offices in Borehamwood.

The application, 25/1781/FUL by Ark Estates 5 Ltd, is for four data centre buildings up to 36.25 metres high on the 7.3-hectare site at the corner of the A41 and Sandy Lane. We reported the full proposal and the 5 November deferral earlier this month.

What has changed

Councillors deferred the scheme “on all grounds”. The addendum answers their questions on water, cooling, generators, noise, air quality, the design and the community payments. The main changes are:

  • New cladding. White and pale blue panels on the upper levels, meant to break up the bulk of the buildings. The height and number of floors are unchanged. Officers say removing or setting back floors would “materially alter the scheme”.
  • Generator tests limited to weekdays. Routine testing of the back-up generators would only happen Monday to Friday, 8am to 8pm, under a new proposed condition.
  • A bigger section 106 package. It now includes money for tree planting along the A41 or at Bushey Jewish Cemetery, local jobs and community projects, carbon offsetting, air quality monitoring and a study into a heat network the site could feed. The amounts are still being negotiated and will be given to councillors on the night.
  • A cross-party group to spend it. The applicant proposes that the community money is managed by a cross-party steering group at the council, including Ark, with any unspent money returned after an agreed period.

The amended plans have gone out to a fresh public consultation. The recommendation is to approve once that ends, provided it raises no new material issues. If it does, the application comes back to committee again.

Water, noise and daylight

Water supply was one of the reasons for the deferral. The applicant says the cooling system would use about twelve times less water a year than the hotel did, and less than 90 homes. A condition would cap its water use.

Officers say whether there is enough water infrastructure is a matter for the water industry’s own regulators, not planning. They quote a recent letter from the Housing Minister, Matthew Pennycook, saying “the planning system should not become a proxy regulator for the regulation of the water industry”.

On noise, cooling plant would add 2 to 3 decibels above background at night at two of the six nearby places tested. Generator testing would add 7 decibels at the Sandy Lane traveller site. The tests would run for an hour once a quarter, plus a four-hour test once a year. Across the site, testing would total up to 126 hours a year in the worst case.

The daylight study found 14 windows in nearby buildings would lose a more significant amount of light, with 3 seeing modest reductions and 35 unaffected. Officers give that harm “moderate weight”.

Data centres at Full Council the night before

On Wednesday 25 November, Full Council debates a Conservative motion on data centres, proposed by Councillor Lynette Sullivan and seconded by Councillor H Cohen.

It notes that the council’s own AECOM economic study gives a central estimate of 10.8 hectares of extra data centre land needed in the borough. Schemes at Potters Bar, Bushey and the Orbital development near junction 24 of the M25 cover about 47.5 hectares, it says, though it accepts the figures are “not directly comparable”.

The motion asks the council leader to meet ministers to seek limits on more data centres in Hertsmere. It also calls for a study of their combined effects. The full text is in the Full Council agenda.

What it means for you

  • Speak at the meeting. One person can speak for the scheme and one against, for three minutes each. You must phone 020 8207 7550 between 10am and 4pm on the day, first come first served, according to the council’s speaking rules.
  • Comment on the amended plans. The new drawings are on the planning file for 25/1781/FUL, and the re-consultation is open now.
  • If you live near the A41 or Sandy Lane, the generator tests would be daytime and weekday only if the condition is attached.