Hertsmere councillors voted 9 to 3 to let all 41 Theobald Street flats be sold privately. The developer had refused a clause to share any later profit.

All 41 flats planned for 26 to 30 Theobald Street in Borehamwood can now be sold on the open market. Hertsmere’s Planning Committee voted 9 to 3 to drop the eight affordable homes the scheme had promised. One councillor abstained.

The vote was taken on Thursday 8 October. The council published the minutes on 23 October, which is the first public record of the result.

Councillors asked the developer, Mandale Homes, for a clawback clause. That would have let the council share in any profit if house prices rose. The developer said no. The council’s own viability consultant told the meeting such a refusal was “not typical”, but that the application could not be turned down because of it.

What the committee decided

The committee did not grant permission outright. It delegated the decision to the Head of Planning, subject to two things:

  • a deed of variation to the section 106 legal agreement, which is the document that removes the eight affordable flats
  • the conditions in the officers’ report and update sheet, minus condition 16

Condition 16 covers the construction traffic plan: lorry numbers and routes, site access, wheel washing and delivery times kept clear of school runs. The developer had asked to have its plan signed off as part of this application. The officers’ report says that plan was still awaiting comment from the county’s highways team. Councillors took it out, so the developer must apply again separately before it can be approved.

On 26 October the council’s planning register still listed application 25/1512/VOC as “awaiting decision”. The formal notice follows once the deed of variation is signed.

How the vote went

The motion was proposed by Councillor C Gray and seconded by Councillor M Handley.

Vote Councillors
For (9) M Allen, M Amron, C Gray, M Handley, A Kaza, P Kaza, D Lambert, L Silver, L Smith
Against (3) G Briski, P Morris, N Susman
Abstained (1) B Rosehill

Why the clawback was not required

Before the meeting, councillors had asked whether a review mechanism could go into the legal agreement, or whether a smaller share of affordable homes could be kept. The council’s update sheet records the developer’s answer. Given the scheme’s viability, it said, it could accept neither.

The minutes record the exchange that followed. The viability consultant, from AspinallVerdi, agreed with officers that efforts had been made to keep a review mechanism. It would be difficult to impose one without a formal council policy requiring it. Hertsmere has no such policy.

That matters because of the consultant’s own figures. Its February 2026 assessment found that if sale prices rose 5% and build costs fell 5%, the original scheme with all eight affordable flats would become viable. Without a review clause, the council has no way to claw any of that back.

Other points from the debate, as the minutes record them:

  • Some councillors said the way the application was made and then amended “could be seen as an attempt to undermine the planning process”.
  • The Interim Head of Planning said the decision set no precedent. Any other developer wanting to cut affordable housing would need its own viability assessment for its own site.
  • One councillor said they would rather see homes on this brownfield site than refuse it and have more built on the green belt.

The other two decisions that night

Both were council-led and both went through:

  • 63 Bairstow Close, Borehamwood: permission to split a council-owned house into two homes for affordable rent, granted by 12 votes to 1. The register shows the decision issued on 9 October.
  • The White Hart, South Mimms: listed building consent for new timber windows and a rebuilt northern wall at the council-owned building, granted 13 votes to 0. South Mimms is about four miles north east of Borehamwood.

What it means for you

  • If you are on the housing register, the eight flats promised in 2024 will not be built as affordable homes. Hertsmere’s nine social rent homes at Catterick Way are the nearest new council homes in the pipeline.
  • If you live or work near the site, by the Grove Medical Centre and the northern end of Glenhaven Avenue, the construction traffic plan is not yet approved. It will come back as a separate application, which you can comment on through the planning register.
  • The next Planning Committee is on Thursday 5 November at 6pm. Our Borehamwood planning news page tracks the town’s big schemes.

The background to the scheme, with the full viability figures, is in our earlier report: Theobald Street flats: 8 affordable homes set to be dropped.

Sources