The former St Hilda's School on Bushey High Street can reopen as a nursery for 124 children from six months old. Hertsmere approved the plans on 9 November.

The former St Hilda’s School in Bushey can reopen as a day nursery for around 124 babies and young children. Hertsmere Borough Council granted planning permission on 9 November.

The site on High Street has been empty since the independent girls’ prep school closed in July 2025. The new nursery would take children from six months old up to pre-school age. It would open from 7am to 7pm, Monday to Friday, with 30 to 35 staff.

The decision is recorded against application 26/1047/FUL on the council’s planning register. It was made by officers rather than the Planning Committee.

What has been approved

The officer’s report (PDF) sets out the scheme. It includes:

  • demolition of the newer part of the school building, replaced by a smaller two-storey entrance block set further back from the road
  • a reception on the ground floor of the new block and a soft play room above it
  • baby and toddler rooms on the ground floor, with lower and upper pre-school rooms upstairs
  • separate outdoor play areas for babies, toddlers and pre-school children
  • a 16-space car park with two disabled bays and a pick-up and drop-off area inside the site
  • a separate pedestrian gate from High Street, away from the car entrance
  • covered parking for bikes and buggies

Two trees in poor condition will come down. Others protected by a tree preservation order are kept, with some crowns lifted or reduced.

The council is attaching a condition that limits the use to a creche, day nursery or day centre. That stops the building being turned to other commercial uses without a fresh application.

Why the school closed

St Hilda’s was founded in 1918 and had been on the High Street site since about 1928, according to the applicant’s planning statement (PDF). It joined the Aldenham Foundation in 2011.

The statement says the school came under financial strain after VAT was added to independent school fees. Enrolment was also falling. About 151 pupils were on roll when it closed, against a capacity of 190.

The school’s nursery for two to four year olds was well subscribed, the statement says. It closed at the same time because the two ran together.

The site has since been bought by Karish Holdings Ltd, which applied through NTA Planning Consultants. The statement says the company already runs a nursery in St Albans.

What neighbours said

The council notified 57 neighbours. Seven responded: six objected and none supported.

Objectors questioned whether Bushey needs 124 more nursery places with a falling birth rate. One said Merry Hill infant school’s nursery has 60 places but only 19 children registered. Others raised traffic at drop-off and pick-up, noise and parking.

Officers said the site already had a nursery and a school, so the applicant did not have to prove demand. Competition with other nurseries is not a planning matter, the report says. It also notes that Merry Hill’s nursery takes children from age three, while this one would take babies from six months.

Hertfordshire County Council’s highways team raised no objection. The report concluded the nursery would bring fewer children to the site than the school did, so noise should be no worse than before.

What it means for you

  • Parents of babies and toddlers in Bushey: a large new nursery option is coming to the High Street. No opening date or fees have been published.
  • Neighbours on the High Street and Meadowcroft: the building facing the road gets smaller, and drop-offs move inside the site. Opening hours of 7am to 7pm are longer than a school day.
  • The rest of the old school: the former tennis courts, disused swimming lanes and hall are not part of this permission, the planning statement says.