The Bushey Golf Club deal with Hill and Griggs cannot go ahead as planned. Cabinet has backed drawing up a development brief and testing the market for a sale.
The deal to redevelop the former Bushey Golf and Country Club cannot go ahead as planned, and Hertsmere Borough Council is now being asked to prepare the site for sale. The two developers say they want £370,000 plus VAT back from the council.
The Cabinet report goes to the meeting on Wednesday 11 November, two months after Cabinet backed the scheme. That scheme was around 250 homes paying for a community hub, with a gross budget of up to £31.6 million. It also promised 50% affordable homes and about 60% of the site as public open space.
Updated 13 November: Cabinet agreed the recommendations on 11 November, according to the council’s decision sheet. It recommended that full council instruct officers to prepare a development brief and seek expressions of interest for selling the site, or parts of it, on the open market. Any decision to sell would need a further vote by councillors. The sheet records that the council has made no admission of liability on the £370,000 claim and is taking specialist legal and procurement advice.
What went wrong
The dispute is over who was allowed to sign the contract.
The council picked its partner through a framework run by LHC, a public sector procurement body. Only one bid came in, from a joint venture of Hill and Griggs Homes. LHC issued a letter of intent in February 2025 naming the joint venture as the council’s preferred partner.
On 7 October 2026, LHC wrote to the council saying the contract had to stay with Hill Holdings Ltd, as the appointed framework supplier. Griggs or a joint venture could only sit beneath that contract. LHC said this could still preserve the two firms’ intended 50/50 arrangement, and suggested ways of structuring it, subject to legal advice.
Five days later, Hill and Griggs replied that they would not proceed on that basis. They say the joint venture contracting directly with the council was the agreed position from their first offer in December 2024. They called it “disappointing and frustrating” after nearly two years of work.
The report describes “a material impasse”. It says initial external legal advice is that signing with the joint venture would breach the Public Contracts Regulations 2015 and risk a procurement challenge or judicial review.
The £370,000 claim
Hill and Griggs are asking for £370,000 plus VAT. They say this covers external consultants and advisers only. In return for full payment, they offer to hand over the reports and consultant appointments, and to end the exclusivity agreement.
The council has not accepted the claim and has made no admission of liability. Its report says the sum and the evidence for it need detailed review, and it authorises no payment. The council’s February 2025 letter said members would have to approve any agreement and kept its right to withdraw. The report adds that this must be read alongside the rest of the dealings between the parties.
Officers are taking specialist legal advice on the claim and on the council’s position towards LHC. The report refers to the council’s “consideration of any claim against LHC”. It does not say any claim has been made. It also says the role of agency personnel involved will form part of a review, and that no conclusions have been reached.
What Cabinet is being asked to do
Most of the recommendations ask Cabinet to note what has happened. The one real proposal is that full council should tell officers to:
- prepare a development brief for the site
- seek expressions of interest for selling all or parts of it on the open market
Officers rejected three other routes as the way forward for now:
- selling without a brief, which could limit what the market will pay
- using Hill Holdings as sole contractor, which the two firms have refused
- a fresh procurement, which would take at least 12 months
Preparing a brief does not commit the council to selling. A further report would come to councillors first. The brief could set the number of homes, the affordable share, the open space and the community buildings. The council could also market the homes separately from the hub, nursery, foodstore and car park.
The report lists weakness in the housing and land markets among the risks. It also notes the lead consultant on the project has been stood down.
What it means for you
Nothing changes on the site for now, and the report says current occupiers’ arrangements stay as they are. But the promises made in September are no longer secure. The hub, the 50% affordable homes and the 60% open space would now depend on what any development brief demands and what a buyer will accept.
The council says its aims for the site have not changed. You can attend the Cabinet meeting at the Civic Offices at 6pm on 11 November. The report does not say what full council decided on the scheme on 16 September, and the minutes of that meeting are not yet published.
Have your say